Customer Testimonials

Google logo
Google Nov 15, 2026

Staff was polite, attentive, and enjoyed my rambunctious 2 year old that was very eager to get "Jeep Truck" John was accommodating and flexible working with me, and around my sons nap time. Overall very pleased with my experience.

Google logo
Google Nov 14, 2026

Google logo
Google Nov 13, 2026

Derek was a great salesman. Not high pressure at all .answered every question I asked with great knowledge! Quick easy and effortless ! Gonna send my friend your way to get one one those Captian America Jeeps !

Google logo
Google Nov 5, 2026

Derek Z. Was an exceptional salesman and a great guy to chat with. Between Derek and the help of his great coworkers the process of buying went super smooth!

Google logo
Google Nov 5, 2026

Financed a used car for our company, they took months going back and forth bickering replacing things left and right which didn't fix anything trying to do anything but replace the transmission but in the end they was forced to replace the transmission because it was their fault for selling cars that are not road ready as they don't over look their vehicle and the car we got was a lemon and they took for ever getting it fixed and it didn't help the guys in the office up front can get pretty rude for you trying ... Read More

Google logo
Google Nov 4, 2026

When I had an issue, they were able to get my truck in for service the next day. All employees were extremely friendly.

Google logo
Google Oct 23, 2026

Bought my wife's car from here. Not much of a problem purchasing the car. The problem is. she is complaining about a shimmy while at low speed . 5 to 35 mph. And then there was the big and hard bang . Took it to the service department. The guy said he drove for 4 miles and had another guy ride with him another 4 miles . Said he didn't feel anything and tried to replicate what we said was wrong . Instead of actually putting it on a rack and checking for any other possible problems that could cause the problem. He just calls and ... Read More

Google logo
Google Oct 22, 2026

I have had great dealership experiences and some horrid ones. This dealership does everything the right way, and you can tell they legitimately care about their customers and will go above and beyond for their customers. It’s obvious they prioritize long lasting relationships over the here and now sale/ commission. Deal with absolute confidence.

Google logo
Google Oct 22, 2026

The used car buying experience here was one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had. Avoid at all cost. The sales people are dishonest. They won’t respond when it’s an issues. And honestly some of them are quite rude. That’s just the tip of the iceberg. I won’t even get into the vehicle issues that I had after purchasing that they tried to off load the cost on to me. I absolutely could not believe the conversation that I had with Mark Ferguson incredibly rude. Not only did they misdiagnose my vehicle, they tried to ... Read More

Google logo
Google Oct 22, 2026

Google logo
Google Oct 21, 2026

Fast recall appointment done right on time as promised

Google logo
Google Oct 18, 2026

Google logo
Google Oct 14, 2026

Wonderful people easy to deal with they take their time to explain things

Google logo
Google Oct 14, 2026

Many THANKS ,to JOHN CROSSWHITE and his team for outstanding Hassle Free and No Pressure buying when we purchased a 2015, Super Clean JEEP WRANGLER.. From Sales to Finance and Service BUCKEYE should be your #1 Team for car or truck Sales and Service...THANK YOU AGAIN TEAM BUCKEYE!

Google logo
Google Oct 7, 2026

Highly recommend this place if ever in the market for a new vehicle! Derek was great very patient and extremely helpful and knowledgeable about what I was looking for. I’ve had a SUV before and loved it and wanted to go back to an SUV. Reasonably priced as well.

Google logo
Google Oct 5, 2026

My mom Maylee D. bought a 2017 jeep Renegade for me. The salesman was great and everyone was friendly. They said the vehicle went through their inspection and everything. Needless to say now she is putting 1100.00 in wheel hubs, outer tire rods, and a alignment. Wouldn't recommend you buy a used vehicle from here. Js...

Google logo
Google Oct 3, 2026

While they don’t show this on their website, in texting with them I find out that if you pay cash there is a $2,000 surcharge!!! Insane

Google logo
Google Oct 3, 2026

John Cross did an amazing job helping us find a perfect vehicles. We have gotten three different vehicles off of this dealership and had great experiences Every time. Chris Fulk is a huge asset for the dealership as a sales manager. Super professional, super clean, and willing to go the extra mile to get you the best financing possible.

Google logo
Google Oct 1, 2026

I called in earlier this week and spoke with Bailey Harris about how another dealership did warranty work on my truck and that it wasn't done correctly and so I would like to see if they could resolve my issue and fix the work that is under warranty. She then replied saying she would make me an appointment for today at 10am and that she spoke to her manager about the situation and they would get me taken care of during that appointment. I show up at 10am today and Bailey Harris was the first person I spoke with ... Read More

Google logo
Google Sep 21, 2026

My family just got a van from here and Derek and the team were amazing! 10/10 recommend, we could not be happier!

Google logo
Google Sep 11, 2026

Worked with Matt Ball on purchasing a used Kia EV6 to replace my current one whose lease was ending. At the last moment Kia offered me a huge discount on buying mine out so I did not go through with buying here, BUT Matt was super helpful answering questions taking additional pictures and videos, etc. I especially appreciate that he didn't try to hide or gloss over any issues. He clearly pointed out some small paint defects. I've worked with other sales people that would have left that as a surprise for me after making the long drive ... Read More

Google logo
Google Sep 11, 2026

Google logo
Google Sep 11, 2026

Every person at buckeye was professional and polite!¹

Google logo
Google Sep 11, 2026

Such an easy process! Only took a few hours from the minute I saw the vehicle online til I was driving it off the lot. The staff were very responsive and knowledgeable. Highly recommend!

Google logo
Google Sep 11, 2026

Google logo
Google Sep 5, 2026

Greeted upon entering service station. Taken care of right away. Assisted to waiting room. Recall taken care of right away. Was out the door in approximately 15min.

Google logo
Google Sep 5, 2026

Google logo
Google Sep 2, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 27, 2026

First things first…… Please pay attention to what is coming on all forms in regards to this dealership I plan to upload all information. Do not trust what they tell you at all. I was a wire ready customer and they sold the truck from under me Then they tried to pull a fast one by switching trucks and saying they were going to sell the exact same truck to me When it was a completely different trim package for $5000 more than it could have been purchased for from anywhere else. Extremely bad business. Hopefully, this is a huge warning ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 26, 2026

Really enjoyed my time with the guys and had no pressure

Google logo
Google Aug 26, 2026

Buckeye Super Store Jeep, in Shelby had a Jeep that my wife and I really liked on Facebook. I called the dealership and spoke with Derek Zehner, the salesman about this vehicle. I told him that we were coming up to look at it and we’re a hour away. He said he would have it ready for us to see and test drive. Upon arrival Derek had it ready for us. He explained the vehicle to us and we test drove it. The process was very smooth, no pressure or back and forth. After that we purchased the vehicle. ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 26, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 25, 2026

Not sure what to even say. Started financing this 2022 Honda Accord from these guys a couple months ago back in July, it's November now, the cars been nothing but a constant headache not even a week into owning the car, it would flash the engine light and kick on every light on the dash and go into limp mode breaking down leaving not just me but me and my two year old daughter multiple times from the side of the highway to just in town going to the grocery store. Yes I've taken the car back many many ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 23, 2026

Great experience, very timely, extremely friendly staff.

Google logo
Google Aug 20, 2026

Best experience! The sales rep Andy was polite and awesome as well. Helpful and no hassle.The other staff were very friendly and polite. Yes and by the way what a great Ram truck!

Google logo
Google Aug 18, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 18, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 16, 2026

They have constantly went above and beyond on multiple purchases.

Google logo
Google Aug 12, 2026

My last visit I am very pleased. Everyone in the Service department did a great job putting my running boards on. Thank guys!!!! Paul is a very happy Gladiator 😊

Google logo
Google Aug 9, 2026

Very friendly!

Google logo
Google Aug 8, 2026

Professional

Google logo
Google Aug 2, 2026

From the first phone call to set up the appointment, to picking up my vehicle when the work was complete was a great experience. I felt as though my truck was the most important vehicle they had to work on. The service people are extremely friendly and helpful and the technicians did a great job. I would recommend this facility to everybody.

Google logo
Google Jul 30, 2026

Evan Strong went above my expectations

Google logo
Google Jul 30, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 25, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 23, 2026

I worked with 2 people in the sales team at Buckeye Superstore, Mike and his boss Chris. Mike sent me the out-the-door quote for a truck I was interested in. I asked if he could price match a discount another dealership was willing to give me. He then passed me onto his boss, Chris, who said they do price match other dealer discounts and asked for the details for the other vehicle. I sent them over and he said he would text me back that afternoon. Four days later, after several unanswered calls, Chris called to tell me he just needed ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jul 19, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 16, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 16, 2026

Love The Ride

Google logo
Google Jun 25, 2026

This was our 3rd vehicle we have gotten from Buckeye Superstore. Our first brand new vehicle. We highly recommend them to everyone. Matt Ball is truly my favorite sales guy. He makes you feel like family. We will be back for sure. ❤️❤️❤️

Google logo
Google Jun 20, 2026

Great experience, only had my jeep for half a day, still had a loaner ready.

Google logo
Google Jun 20, 2026

Google logo
Google Jun 17, 2026

Found a gem at this dealership four and half hours away, and everyone there was helpful and kind. Keynen was fantastic to work with through texts, videos and even a FaceTime call that allowed me to look over the vehicle the best I could from almost 300 miles away. Wife and I decided to take a chance and drove to the dealership to see and test drive in person. Keynen did not misrepresent the vehicle and it was worth the trip; the dealer even took care of an unexpected mechanical issue at their expense before we drove it home. Cannot say ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 13, 2026

Derick Zehner was amazing for a newbie salesman. Keynen Zachman did awesome whenever Derek reached out for assistance. Both of these young men showed great respect to my mother who uses a walker. They were on point opening doors and holding doors and just everything you would like to see a young man do they were on point I could not be happier with the vehicle that I was sold, it is not what I went in to get, but it is the best one that I could’ve walked away with thank you again so much for such an ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 13, 2026

Took my jeep in for a recall fixed and out the door in a half hour

Google logo
Google Jun 10, 2026

Great and easy experience!!!

Google logo
Google Jun 10, 2026

Our salesman, Evan Strong, was the absolute best. He was professional but also personable.We found the perfect van for our family and we love it! We will be back for future vehicle purchases.

Google logo
Google Jun 4, 2026

Google logo
Google Jun 4, 2026

Best dealership to go to when your a first time car buyer This place was very professional works very well with you with options to chose from and I was only in their for a half an hour and same day I went home with a beautiful jeep definitely recommend this place and Mike was very kind and will come again!.

Google logo
Google Apr 4, 2026

After collecting all my personal information, the refused to negotiate the price of a used vehicle. Then they randomly lowered the advertised price on the next day. They like to talk about transparent pricing, but the truth is they don't even know when or why the pricing changes. They talk about cost of advertising, but how much does it cost to put a listing on a website? It's a very frustrating experience. Do not believe they really wanted to earn my business. Cannot recommend.

Google logo
Google Mar 16, 2026

I’m reducing their rating from three stars to two because I tried to get a deal on this car that I bought because of the condition of the seats. I tried to get them down $1000 because I would have to have these cars detailed more than once, very heavily, which cost a lot of money. There are some other minor details like the underbody splash guard having to be replaced immediately, Which is also costly. They replied to my initial review telling me to come in and schedule a cleaning. The car looks a SLIGHTLY better, but also worse. ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 28, 2026

-10000 stars this is the worst service ever my mom got a jeep here and it’s been in the shop since November almost we got it back and within 4 hours it had to be taken back. I went today to pick it up and it died I went in and I complained they stood their looking at me like I was stupid but they keep giving us the run around about the vehicle which is very unprofessional and they keep charging and charging us but won’t actually fix the vehicle at this point in time my mom is gonna ... Read More

Google logo
Google Dec 9, 2025

Incompetent had a service Olive was to order a part. I had to call and speak to the parts department because she never bothered to have the part ordered. There are also some very inconsiderate employees that the work here, especially if you're an educated female. One would think when you're spending hundreds of dollars for service that you would at least be treated with some respect. This seems to a common situation with male employees of some of the other Jeep places Mansfield, Shelby, Norwalk.

Google logo
Google Oct 1, 2025

Had thee worst experience ever with buying a car the management is very dishonest had a brought a truck the window was chipped it eventually cracked due to how long it took them to get to window guy they then replaced it but wouldn't fix the tint besides the salesperson Evan the experience was horrible may I add i hated the service and disrespectful management but Evan was superb besides him the company sux

Google logo
Google Aug 28, 2025

Just sell your vehicles. I don't care for your personal feelings or political positions.

Google logo
Google Jul 25, 2025

DONT SHOP HERE. Andy messed up the deal. Matt who in my personal opinion is one of the worst salesman I have ever met. From his attitude, using discounts, and lying about suspension work. I buy a new car about every two years. This guy told me "its a process" and I swear purposely made us wait longer. To honor some of the pricing they gutted the trade to attempt to make their money back. Even though we agreed to numbers over the phone. KBB average condition (meaning some little things will need to be addressed). They cried ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jul 12, 2025

Excellent service department. Jonathan and Olivia are very helpful. The technician does a very thorough job checking my Jeep. And the work is done right.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google May 11, 2025

DO NOT RECOMMEND this place of business!!!…I am a Veteran…I saw a vehicle listed on autotrader and reached out to the Buckeye Superstore. I spoke with the salesman, John Crosswhite, the day before to inquire about the availability of a vehicle. He confirmed that the vehicle was still available. I then researched the vehicle on Carfax only to learn that the vehicle had prior minor damage which was not divulged on the auto trader listing of the car…The vehicle was listed as a Certified Used vehicle. After inquiring about the minor repair, with the salesman, he reached ... Read More

Google logo
Google Apr 21, 2025

Worst service experience I’ve ever had! I do not suggest taking a vehicle to them to be looked at. They don’t know how to diagnose so they tell you nothings wrong. Bring it back because issue persists they send it off to somewhere else to get looked at because again they can’t figure it out and boom entire engine needs replaced. Guess what, now the warranty has run out and it’s on us to pay for it because we are just past the warranty. Had it been diagnosed and fixed previously the warranty would have been ... Read More

Google logo
Google Apr 4, 2025

We got a vehicle last week and we paid for it and we took it to a garage and found out there is more damage than the car is worth and it is very hazardous to be on the road

Google logo
Google Mar 20, 2025

Google logo
Google Mar 12, 2025

I’ve never had luck with this store. Poor management they act like gods. They are awful. Was looking to sell my wife’s vehicle salesman was top notch. Shout out to Andy. This isn’t his fault. They hit low on the price. I have another offer for way more money I tried selling local. They go in the back throw my car on the scanner find a fault code from FOURTY THOUSAND MILES AGO and hit 4k less because of that. Oh and it needs tires when the tires are fine. I won’t be back. Ever. I ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Mar 6, 2025

He was very polite and professional. He answered all the questions I had about the vehicle and told me more that I didn’t think about, overall I would definitely ask for him. The next time I come and get a car.

Read at DealerRater

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Mar 6, 2025

Working with Nate was a great experience. He is knowledgeable about the business and strives to get you in the perfect vehicle. I would recommend him to anyone looking for their next vehicle purchase. Thank you Nate for making my experience so pleasant and fast.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Feb 2, 2025

Car was in service to fix a locking issue with the drivers door when using the key fob. Took it in the first time in October. It was in and out 5 times. Last time they had the car for a month. I didn’t get the car back until right before Christmas. When I got the car back, the locking issue was fixed, however, the car was now displaying an error message “service keyless entry” in the dash. There was no way I was taking it back Buckeye. I took the car to another dealer and they found that a ... Read More

Google logo
Google Dec 6, 2024

Worst Dealership Ever. I Basically Had A Brand New Jeep Grand Cherokee That I’m Financing For $35,000. I Took My SUV There To Get Lifters Fixed. When I Got my Car out of there Care it sounded like a helicopter. My vehicle never sounded like that. Now they want to tell me I have heavy duty cooling fan it’s suppose to sound like that smh. If I go to a restaurant an order food I have to shut my vehicle off because the car is extremely loud. I have had my vehicle for 18months before I took it “buckeye ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Dec 2, 2024

The service department was very thorough in handling the warranty repair work. The customer service representative explained what needed to be done. When the parts arrived they called and set up a time to do the repair.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Nov 15, 2024

Communication is terrible..

Google logo
Google Nov 8, 2024

This is the worst car I have ever owned. Had the car for a year and already need a new ENGINE. I will never do business with them again.

Google logo
Google Oct 15, 2024

I purchased a certified 23 Grand Cherokee l from Buckeye 9/27/24. I was looking for a specific model which they had so I drove 4 hours to pick it up. When I got there the vehicle was not ready and I ended up sitting around for quite a while. At the end of the day I went into the finance guy and as I was signing the forms he sprang a dissatisfaction report from the previous owner on me. He sat there and assured me the vibration problem was fixed due to the fact it was certified. So I went on my way, ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jul 2, 2024

They have always taken care of my vehicles, and no exception today. Very thorough and very quick with the service.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google May 9, 2024

Got my jeep 3 months ago and came in for a free oil change that was covered under my warranty and ended up spending $500 on a new battery and cabin filter. Shouldn’t these things be checked before hand? There’s no way the battery went to crap after 3 months!!

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Apr 29, 2024

Friendly people Knowledge of my car Explained what work was performed on my car Told me when to schedule next appt.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Apr 13, 2024

No good

Google logo
Google Feb 26, 2024

Good experience , they always take good care of me.

Google logo
Google Feb 22, 2024

Went in to trade our 12 traverse in with nothing specific in mind. We asked for recommendations with complete honesty of what we knew we could afford. Within the process we even raised our monthly allowance. We knew coming in we were asking for a fair priced vehicle with lower miles on it (an easter egg if you will) however Matt found a vehicle we liked and stated it would be close to our monthly allowance for a vehicle. Right after they turned around and offered us $1000 for our current traverse and failed to give an explanation on why? We were ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Feb 14, 2024

Salesperson Mike very well informed of van,easy to get financed agreat experience in car buying

Read at DealerRater

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jan 26, 2024

After searching far and wide we found a great deal that met all of our needs. Our salesman John was very friendly and not overly aggressive. Everyone was very friendly and polite.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Jan 25, 2024

Just make sure the car you’re driving to check out (i drove 4 and a half hours, 209 miles to buy a car from Buckeye Auto) runs and drives. The car gave out, limp mode as soon as i drove off of the lot. “I feel sorry for you” the salesman said. It was really psychotic that they let me drive 4 and a half hours (209 miles) to their dealership when they knew the car wasn’t able. Other than that, not a terrible experience.

Google logo
Google Dec 31, 2023

Google logo
Google Nov 19, 2023

Very bad experience with salesman Mike. Never have I been so disrespected in my life. We considered buying a vehicle there but after how he talked to me, my husband and I decided we no longer were interested in doing business there. We left as at that point no amount of trade in value was worth being treated and talked to how I was. Complete waste of our time and really sad we were treated so badly. My husband and his family always loved getting his vehicles here but have since reconsidered.

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Nov 6, 2023

Not liking my payment price should not of agreed to it. My lease payment was more affordable

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Oct 14, 2023

Took 3 Weeks to get my truck fixed. I ended up ordering the part myself and delivering it (a factory Mopar part). I got it in 2 days while they continued to tell me they were still waiting for a delivery date. Other than that part was put on and truck runs now. Just a ridiculous down time for me to be without a truck

Google logo
Google Aug 21, 2023

December 2022 I purchased a 2012 Buick Regal less than 100,000 miles. There was an oil leak the dealer tried to fix which was/is assumed to cause extreme fumes that quickly displace the air in the cab. I've had several mechanical issues and the vehicle was overpriced. I made a poor choice however this car NEVER should have been on the lot for sale. No one checks these vehicles out adequately. My advice, DO NOT purchase used vehicles from this dealership.

Google logo
Google Jul 9, 2023

Awful. Sales was very terrible. Sales staff had nasty attitudes and didn’t even let us look at the vehicle we came for. Take your business elsewhere. Don’t waste your time.

DealerRater logo
DealerRater May 27, 2023

2nd time working with Chris Fulk, always great working with him. He has gotten me what I was looking for both times. Will definitely be working with Chris for all my future purchases.

Read at DealerRater

DealerRater logo
DealerRater May 24, 2023

The service I received on my Jeep Cherokee was expertly preformed. The entire process was very easy and efficient.

Read at DealerRater

DealerRater logo
DealerRater May 18, 2023

Great dealership nice compass highly recommended good prices clean premises super staff will deal with again

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google May 16, 2023

1.5 hrs for oil change and tire rotation. They broke wheel stud off and wanted to charge me over $300 to fix it.. also didn't use my second free oil Change within a yr. So they wanted to charge me for the free oil change. So no I will NOT be returning to this service department.

Google logo
Google May 14, 2023

We have purchased 2 vehicles from Buckeye Superstore with no issues. Recently had our Journey in for some warranty work, and I can't say the same. After receiving our vehicle back from service within 100 miles had a spark plug blow out of the cylinder head that wasn't tightened properly. I'm sure they would have resolved the issue but wasn't happy about it so chose to have the repairs done elsewhere. In response to the response, plugs were not changed but checked. When reinstalled one appears to have been left loose.


Leave Us A Review